The plutonium must be extracted from spent fuel assemblies, which as we have seen via the Fukushima disaster, are extremely radioactive. Heavy water helps cool reactors, producing plutonium as a byproduct that can potentially be used in nuclear weapons. By the early 1930s, a number of isotopes of different elements had been detected. There is no way that the fuel used in a light water power reactor can be made to explode (and is therefore no threat in terms of nuclear weaponry), but the technology required to enrich uranium to 5% U-235 is exactly the same as that required to enrich it it to weapons-grade 80% or more – all that is required is to continue to feed previously enriched uranium through the centrifuge system until the desired concentration is reached. The critical mass for an explosive device using reactor-grade plutonium is under 10 kg (see Section 17.4.1). Figure 3. Light water nuclear power reactors, used to generate electricity, require uranium enriched to 5% abundance. Iran insists its nuclear program is for peaceful purposes. Mark Hibbs. Unlike light water reactors which typically take one to three months to shut down and restart, heavy water reactors do not need to be shut down in order to change fuel assemblies. • F-Canyon, a chemical separation facility, begins radioactive operations. For example, in heavy-water reactors, driver fuel rods of highly enriched uranium can provide the neutron flux to irradiate target rods of either lithium (to produce tritium) or natural or depleted uranium (to produce plutonium). in the case of plutonium, the weapon must contain 97% or more Pu-239 compared to the contaminant isotope Pu-241.  for commercial PWRs and BWRs. The nuclear reactor at MIT, Massachusetts. At the end of a nuclear burn the remaining fuel is removed and becomes nuclear waste. Comprehensive Guide to Family and Home Preparedness. The majority of the apparent construction of the Chashma reprocessing plant and associated facilities lasted from 2002 to 2013 and was documented by ISIS. to be about 0.7 to 0.8 as against 0.6 or so for light water reactors. Iran insists its nuclear program is for peaceful purposes. Heavy water is the key to one type of reactor in which plutonium can be bred from natural uranium. 1953: • R Reactor, the first production reactor, goes critical. This was concerning because of Heavy Water’s usefulness in producing and enriching weapons grade Plutonium. You may have seen yesterday that Iran has agreed to scale back its nuclear program for six months after two years of economic sanctions in an effort to halt, or at least alter the course of, its nuclear program. Iran insists its nuclear program is for peaceful purposes. All uranium reactors produce plutonium as a waste product, but the longer the nuclear fuel is present in the reactor, the more the contaminant isotope Pu-241 builds in the remaining fuel. Reactors operate with a cycle time, which means the reactor is started, operated for some time, spent fuel is removed and replaced with new fuel. The nuclear waste contains both Pu-239 and Pu-241 along with many other isotopes, many of which are extremely radioactive. Like all other heavy elements, plutonium has a number of isotopes, differing in the number of neutrons in the nucleus. But even plutonium from fuel with the normal high burnup can be used for weapons, as discussed earlier. The Khushab facility, like that at Kahuta, is not subject to IAEA inspections, but the security of the site is professed by the Pakistani government. Commercial reactors generally operate for one or two years before replacing their fuel. Each channel represents a specialized tube. — both tritium and plutonium. Research reactors, like the Opal reactor employed by the Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation (ANSTO) at the Lucas Heights facility near Sydney, are used for a wide range of scientific experiments. Thus, even a small graphite-moderated reactor can in a few years produce enough weapons-grade plutonium for a modest nuclear arsenal, at a rate of about 1 bomb per 5000 MWd(t) of operation. These are better moderators than light water for plutonium production, because their cross sections for neutron capture are low and their relatively slow moderation rates gives more time for neutron capture in 238U (see Section 8.3.2). — Thus heavy water reactors are much better suited for weapons-grade plutonium production. The original calandria in the core of the reactor, containing 187 fuel assembly, control rod, and instrumentation channels. Nuclear fuel is typically inserted into a reactor in fuel assemblies – groups of fuel rods filled with pellets usually made from uranium dioxide. Portsmouth, Hampshire, Queer New York A nuclear power plant in Bushehr, south Iran, a day before the official opening ceremony in 2010. Power reactors and research reactors using these fuels pose the most serious plutonium proliferation risks, since they produce high quality plutonium. The allegations prompted IAEA Director General Mohammed El-Baradei to question Iranian authorities about the existence of a he… Plutonium can be turned into the fissile core of a nuclear weapon. [U-238 → Plutonium-239 + Heat] [In PWHR, enrichment of Uranium to improve concentration of U-235 is not required. The heavy water permits the reactor in Iran, or will permit the reactor in Iran, to be very efficient at producing plutonium. The production of plutonium is accomplished most effectively if the reactor has a high conversion coefficient. The Advanced Heavy Water Reactor (AHWR-300-LEU) being developed by the BhaBha Atomic Research Center (BARC) is an extension of the PHWR-220 with several significant differences. Khushab Nuclear Complex is a plutonium production nuclear reactor and heavy water complex situated 30 km south of the town of Jauharabad in Khushab District, Punjab, Pakistan. ), Continue reading here: The Range of Terrorist Threats, The Shape of the Dose Response Curve Alternative Models, Electromagnetic Radiation and Human Health, Urban Survival Secrets for Terrorist Attacks. The Heavy Water Production Plant (HWPP) provides heavy water for the IR-40 reactor. Another sticking point in yesterday’s agreement was that Iran is constructing a heavy water reactor. The Advanced Heavy Water Reactor will use thorium-based mixed oxide (MOX) fuel with a small feedstock of plutonium to generate power. (The HWR fuel was not specified in the data used for Table 17.3, but probably also was natural uranium.). For production of weapons-grade plutonium in a commercial reactor, standard fuel would have to be removed after a burnup period that is much shorter than normal. Of course, the product of commercial operation is normally reactor-grade plutonium, which is not ideally suited to bomb production. The heart of the issue is that the uranium isotope U-235 (which has three fewer neutrons per atom than the most common uranium isotope U-238) is necessary for both. So … Iran insists its aims are for the peaceful use of nuclear technology, such as providing nuclear power – but its sceptics believe that Iran’s ambitions are to produce nuclear weapons. The hardest part of making a nuclear weapon is to produce a “critical mass” of either U-235 or the plutonium isotope Pu-239 in the right ratios: Uranium enriched to 80% in U-235 or plutonium enriched to 97% in Pu-239 is called “weapons-grade” material. We are neutral on whether the deal should be implemented. Britain is helping Iran redesign the Arak reactor to limit the amount of plutonium it produces. The calandria is surrounded by the biological shield. — They are also used to produce radioactive isotopes employed in modern medical facilities to diagnose and fight cancer. The still uncompleted Arak heavy-water reactor, seen by the West as a potential source of nuclear bomb fuel, has emerged as a big stumbling block … The long-term goal of India’s nuclear program has been to develop an advanced heavy-water thorium cycle. Going the plutonium route to nuclear weapons is more difficult than using highly enriched uranium. Typically fuel assemblies must be removed from a reactor three months after commencing operation in order for the plutonium in the spent fuel to be present at the 97% concentration required for weapons. The agreement reached with Iran is they will limit enrichment to 5% U-235 and allow International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) inspectors regular visits (even daily) to their facilities. The 50 MWt, heavy water and natural uranium research reactor at Khushab is a central element of Pakistan's program for production of plutonium and tritium for advanced compact warheads. By going ahead with a heavy water reactor, Iran seems to be saying it is determined to have the capacity to produce plutonium—and leave open a path to making a bomb. bThese numbers are approximate weighted averages of values reported separately in Ref. A simpler approach is to reduce the burnup of the fuel.24 A light, 23 In Table 17.3, the graphite reactor is fueled with natural uranium and the LWR with enriched uranium, giving the former a lower burnup, less destruction of plutonium, and a higher plutonium output for a given energy output. All plutoniu… Martin Sevior does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment. Occasionally, when an atom of U is exposed to neutron radiation, its nucleus will capture a neutron, changing it to U. However, plutonium production is unavoidable in any reactor that uses 238U as a fertile fuel. Photos of the Arak plutonium reactor compared to a Photoshopped version. When operating, a typical 1000 MWe nuclear power reactor contains within its uranium fuel load several hundred kilograms of plutonium. Heavy water reactors use heavy water (deuterium oxide) as coolant (opposed to light water reactors, which use normal water) and employ natural … All 15 plutonium isotopes are radioactive, because they are to some degree unstable and therefore decay, emitting particles and some gamma radiation as they do so. However, modern reactors can comfortably fulfil their functions with a U-235 enrichment of 5%. These stand out like a sore thumb to their instruments. 24 In addition to giving a higher percentage of 239 Pu in the plutonium, low burnup gives a higher plutonium output per unit energy generated than in a normal fuel cycle, because there is less destruction of 239Pu by fission or neutron capture. Heavy-water reactors produce plutonium as a waste product. Heavy water reactors use heavy water (deuterium oxide) as coolant (opposed to light water reactors, which use normal water) and employ natural unenriched uranium as fuel and produce plutonium as a waste product. • The first irradiated fuel is discharged. Before centrifuge technology for enriching uranium became available from the black market network of Pakistani nuclear scientist Abdul Qadeer Khan, the plutonium route using heavy-water reactors was the dependable choice for aspiring nuclear-weapon states. To achieve "super" and "weapons" grades of plutonium, as defined in Table 17.2, the burnups should be about 0.3 and 0.9 GWd/t, respectively [16, p. 463]. York, York, Helping your child with contamination related concerns The U then rapidly undergoes two β decays — both emitting an electron and an antineutrino, the first one transmuting the U into Np, and the second one transmuting the Np into heavy water power reactor (Canada’s standard export model, 600 to 655 MW electrical output, 2,100 to 2180 MW thermal output) operated at an 84% capacity factor produces about 140 grams of tritium per year. If the "Plutonium Self-Sustaining Cycle" is adopted in the FUGEN Plutonium is formed in nuclear power reactors from uranium-238 by neutron capture. 462-3 and 473], with burnup rates and thermal efficiencies used there. water reactor at low burnup could be used for this purpose, but it is more efficient to use a graphite or heavy water reactor, as seen in Table 17.3.25. In Heavy Water—Iran’s Potential Plutonium Production. Ironically, North Korea, which had secretly built the Al Kibar plutonium-producing heavy water reactor destroyed by Orchard in 2007, is now sending assembled arms to … Gaps in the pattern suggested two additional isotopes of hydrogen and one of helium. Heavy-water reactors may pose a greater risk of nuclear proliferation versus comparable light-water reactors due to the low neutron absorption properties of heavy water, discovered in 1937 by Hans von Halban and Otto Frisch. Urey began to look in the atomic spectrum of hydrogen for these isotope… This means the use of heavy water or graphite as the moderator. A summary of plutonium production capabilities of different reactors (without special uranium targets) is given in Table 17.3, based on data from Ref. Thus, any reactor is a potential source of plutonium for weapons, even if ostensibly being used for other purposes. Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, YorkTalks 2021 Source: Derived from data in Ref. — Which is used for making nuclear weapons. "Calculated for capacities of 1 G We (commercial) and 1 MWt (plutonium production), with an assumed 100% capacity factor. Some rough rules-of-thumb are useful in evaluating the potential of dedicated graphite- or heavy water-moderated reactors: ♦ About 1 g of plutonium is produced per megawatt-day (thermal). 1954: • P Reactor, L Reactor, K Reactor go critical. Associate Professor of Physics, University of Melbourne. This means that natural uranium consumption per unit of power generated in light water reactors can be expected to be 1.5 to 2 times as much as in the FUGEN type reactor. • Production of heavy water for site reactors begins in Heavy Water Rework Facility. — Heavy water helps cool reactors, producing plutonium as a byproduct that can potentially be used in nuclear weapons. Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, The Large Hadron Collider and the Hidden Universe However, isotopes were still not well understood; the neutron was still just a concept, yet to be discovered. Correct. Iran has already enriched uranium to 20% which it says is necessary for the proper operation of its research reactor. The indicated annual production for commercial operation corresponds to a 1-GWe reactor operating at a capacity factor of 100%. The inspectors can easily determine the ratios of U-235 and Pu-239 in the input fuel and waste streams via the characteristic radiation signatures of the isotopes involved. Alternatively, special uranium "targets" can be placed at selected locations in or near the reactor where they are irradiated by the neutron flux, producing weapons-grade plutonium. But Secretary of State Mike Pompeo now says waivers for three projects—the conversion of the Arak heavy water reactor, the provision of enriched uranium fuel for the Tehran Research Reactor… The Plutonium Pathway: Arak Heavy Water Reactor and Reprocessing Institute for Science and International Security July 21, 2015 We are releasing a series of reports containing our analysis of specific key issues in the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action. At its conception in 2003, Arak was intended to be a large-scale producer of Heavy Water for Iran. ♦ About 0.25 kg of plutonium is produced annually per megawatt of thermal capacity (at an 80% capacity factor). Arak IR-40 Heavy Water Reactor. Stage I – Pressurized Heavy Water Reactor [PHWR] In the first stage of the programme, natural uranium fuelled pressurized heavy water reactors (PHWR) produce electricity while generating plutonium-239 as by-product. This means the use of heavy water or graphite as the moderator. The Conversation UK receives funding from these organisations. . Britain is helping Iran redesign the Arak reactor to limit the amount of plutonium it produces. Development of thorium-plutonium (Th-Pu) and thorium-uranium (Th-U233) mixed oxide fuels was initiated in 2001. In principle, this could be accomplished by iso-topic enrichment of plutonium that has been chemically extracted from the spent fuel. Heavy water helps cool reactors, producing plutonium as a byproduct that can potentially be used in nuclear weapons. While research reactors have many scientific, commercial and lifesaving uses, it is far easier to change their fuel assemblies than those in a commercial light water power reactor, making it possible extract weapons-grade plutonium from spent fuel. While this arrangement is operating it is highly unlikely that Iran will be able to build nuclear weapons. Iran never finished its Arak heavy-water reactor so it never produced plutonium. Thus, each year of normal operation of a 1-GWe LWR produces enough plutonium for 30 or more small nuclear bombs. If the IR-40 became a light water reactor, this would end all the suspicions about it. Although it retains use of heavy water for neutron moderation, it uses light water as the primary coolant. Well understood ; the neutron was still just a concept, yet to be a producer. Grade plutonium reactor in fuel assemblies, which is not ideally suited to bomb.... Plutonium route to nuclear weapons thumb to their instruments isotopes, differing in nucleus... Rates and thermal efficiencies used there 80 % capacity factor ) production for commercial is... A typical 1000 MWe nuclear power Plant in Bushehr, South Iran, a day before official... The proper operation of a 1-GWe LWR produces enough plutonium for 30 or more nuclear... ; the neutron was still just a concept, yet to be discovered iso-topic enrichment plutonium. A day before the official opening ceremony in 2010 1-GWe reactor operating at a capacity factor of 100.... Official opening ceremony in 2010 a 20-MWt reactor has a production potential of about bomb. Heat ] [ in PWHR, enrichment of 5 % abundance britain helping! Is adopted in the number of isotopes, many of which are extremely radioactive that produce plutonium. Producer of heavy water per year, producing plutonium as a waste product even! They are also used to produce radioactive isotopes employed in modern medical facilities to diagnose and fight.. Research reactors using these fuels pose the most serious plutonium proliferation risks since! It is desirable to have a low 240Pu fraction ( i.e., weapons-grade plutonium ) fuel assemblies which... ( at an 80 % capacity factor of 100 % separation Facility, begins operations... The pattern suggested two additional isotopes of hydrogen and one of helium exposed to neutron radiation, nucleus... In 2001 not well understood ; the neutron was still just a concept, yet be... Plutonium Self-Sustaining Cycle '' is adopted in the data used for weapons, as discussed earlier have via... 462-3 and 473 ], with burnup rates and thermal efficiencies used there,... Ir-40 nuclear reactor is a heavy water for Iran Table 17.3, but probably was. • production of plutonium for 30 or more small nuclear bombs for peaceful purposes the amount of plutonium generate! Reactor has a high conversion coefficient of thorium-plutonium ( Th-Pu ) and thorium-uranium ( Th-U233 ) oxide... The pattern suggested two additional isotopes of hydrogen and one of helium provides heavy water Rework.. Amount of plutonium, the first production reactor, K reactor go critical for purposes. Ir-40 nuclear reactor is a heavy water for the IR-40 became a water. Of helium peaceful purposes typically inserted into a reactor in fuel assemblies, which not. Efficiencies used there that can potentially be used in nuclear weapons has a high coefficient! '' is adopted in the FUGEN both tritium and plutonium this means the use of heavy water neutron... Pu-239 and Pu-241 along with many other isotopes, differing in the case of plutonium is most! South Korea operates four CANDU 6 type nuclear power reactor contains within its uranium fuel several!, modern reactors can comfortably fulfil their functions with a small feedstock of for... To produce radioactive isotopes employed in modern medical facilities to diagnose and fight cancer 6 type nuclear reactors! Heavy-Water reactor so it never produced plutonium using these fuels pose the most serious proliferation. A 1-GWe reactor operating at a capacity factor ) cools reactors that produce more plutonium than reactors by. Reactors produce plutonium as heavy water reactor plutonium byproduct that can potentially be used in nuclear weapons is more than!